Wed 3 Feb 2010
The NECAPS are out and I looked through them briefly to see how we are doing. Dr. Brennan presented some information at the District Leadership Team meeting last week. There is some encouraging news and some things we need to work on.
I stole Dr. Brennan’s idea of making graphs showing progress, but I also added the current year’s state averages for comparison. For example, if you look at the high school math scores and see that only 27% of students scored proficient or above, it might give you a heart attack until you see that only 33% of 11th graders in the entire state scored proficient or above in math. We also have an average number of high school students scoring proficient or above in reading and although I didn’t make a chart, our high school students dominated the writing test. The average score in the state was a 6.5 and our average score was a 6.9. Central’s average score was a 7.4! Let’s have a little cheering and fist pumping for our high school teachers and students.
There was a story in the paper on Tuesday about how Goffstown High School improved their test scores considerably over last year by offering students incentives to do well and by having proctors who knew the students. Last year their scores were similar to ours, but his year 88% of the students scored proficient in Reading and 48% scored proficient in Math. It might be worth sending some spies over.
Mark Twain once said that there are three kinds of lies; lies, damn lies, and statistics. Nevertheless I really like looking at the data. Setting it up this way gives you the bird’s eye view of what is going on. You can look at progress at individual grade levels and you can follow cohorts of students by looking diagonally. I noticed that the 4th grade reading scores didn’t go up as much as the other grades for example. Does the curriculum at that grade level need to be adjusted? Do the teachers need additional resources or training? Is it that cohort of kids? They were at 59% in third grade and they are at 59% in 4th. The cohort before them went from 61% in 3rd, down to 58% in 4th, and back up to 66% in 5th. It just gives you something to think about.
Here are the graphs. Some of them got a little cut off on the side but you get the idea.




I used the district-wide scores but you can look at the scores for your individual schools by visiting the NH DOE website
I also looked at the scores of ELL students. As you know, the school district sent a letter to the state asking that ELL students not be tested for two years after they come into the system and for an additional 3 years if they have never been to school.
I took exception to that. First, because we have serious, systemic problems that affect all of our children and we ought to focus on that and I don’t think it is right to single out a group of students as the cause of our problems.
I also think that this promotes a one dimensional view of ELL students. We are made to believe that more and more ELL students are flooding our system and that most of them have never been to school and neither have their parents. Well, that depends. The Somali Bantu were prohibited from getting an education because the larger ethnic group wanted to insure that the Bantu would be available for menial labor. Nevertheless, my friend Geraldine enjoys working with them becuse they are respectful and work hard. The most recent group of refugees from Bhutan have many educated adults among them and they educated their children in the camps. When I talk to people from the immigrant and refugee communities they think our perception that the United States is the only place in the world that has good schools is a little ethnocentric.
I looked at a few of the most recent NECAP results to see how the Limited English Proficiency students did. 37% of 3rd grade LEP students were proficient in reading. Among the students in the second monitoring year after being mainstreamed, 92% were proficient in reading. Among English speakers it was 68%. While newcomers are exempt from the reading portion of the exam, they do take the math portion. A translator helps. In 4th grade, 35% of LEP students were proficient, and 65% of English Speakers were.
I also tried to find total numbers of ELL students. According to the NH DOE in 2000 there were 1,326 LEP students in our school district or 7.62%. In 2008, which is the last year they have data available, there were 942 LEP students or 5.78%. The actual percentage of LEP students is declining and I’m told that ½ of our ELL students are now American-born children of foreign-born parents, just like my mother.
I expect the next large group of ELL students will come from Haiti and they will have a variety of abilities. If they aren’t tested, we’ll never know. In the interest of transparency I think the public needs to know who the kids are in our schools and what their challenges are. ELL kids are not all alike, they have different backgrounds, different abilities, and different aspirations.
Luckily, when the ESEA act gets renewed a lot of the punitive aspects of No Child Left Behind will disappear, however standards based assessment and transparency are here to stay.


